A/B Testing Is Dead

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🧠 Why Smart Teams Are Switching to A→A→B Testing

📊 Meta Launches ‘Opportunity Score’ for All Advertisers

🎥 Ad of the Day 

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with dofollow.com

AI can’t cite what it can’t find.

AI is reshaping how your buyers discover products. But here’s the catch: it only cites what it sees.

If your content isn’t earning backlinks from respected sources, you won’t rank, and you won’t get mentioned by AI.

That’s where dofollow.com comes in. They help SaaS teams earn editorial links from sites your buyers (and Google) actually trust. 

Because if you’re not showing up there, your competitors are.

Here's what real SaaS brands achieved with them:

• NectarHR went from 0 to 50+ demos a month and saw 3900% increase in traffic
• Heymarket’s top keyword jumped 65+ positions, driving a 6× traffic lift.

Check out how top brands earn links AI actually cites.

See it in action today!

🧠 A/B Is Dead: Why Smart Teams Are Switching to A→A→B Testing

Everyone tells you to test fast. But no one talks about how that speed warps the results. If you’re still running traditional A/B tests in eComm, you’re probably chasing ghosts.

Here’s the problem:

Classic A/B assumes two things:

1. Each user journey is isolated in time.
2. Audience segments never overlap.

But in real-world DTC, especially on Meta, TikTok, and email, those assumptions break down daily. Audiences mix. Algorithms optimize. Memory stacks. A new variant doesn’t land in a vacuum. It lands in the aftertaste of your last winner. That’s where A→A→B comes in.

What is A→A→B Testing?

Instead of showing A vs B at the same time, you show A repeatedly, then introduce B after A has accumulated attention, familiarity, and expectations.

Why this works:

• It mirrors the natural journey of real customers.
• It helps detect fatigue vs actual preference.
• It reveals whether a new concept works standalone or just looks good in contrast.

You’re not just testing “which converts better.” You’re testing resilience, decay, and contextual lift.

Where it shines in DTC:

1. Offer testing – Run your current offer for 10 days (A). Then test the new offer with the same audiences (B). If performance jumps after people were saturated on A, it’s likely a strong new pull.
2. Creative testing – Rotate your top-performing UGC or ad (A) until its CTR dips. Then launch B to see if it genuinely revives performance or cannibalizes what remains.
3. Landing pages – Don’t split traffic too early. Build narrative tension on A, then introduce B to your most exposed cohorts to test clarity + novelty response. 

And here’s where UGC fits in…

How to operationalize this (without breaking your team):

You need modular assets that can rotate smoothly between A and B variations across platforms.

That’s where tools like Insense quietly shine, enabling you to spin up 5–10 variant creatives fast, sourced from vetted creators who actually follow your brief. No creative burnout. No weeks of delay. Just tactical firepower for progressive testing. You can book a strategy call with Insense here and get up to 20% off managed service.

In Conclusion, Most A/B tests lie. They reward novelty, not longevity.

But A→A→B tests show you what actually works when it matters: when the audience already knows you, and still wants more. If you’re ready to stop testing in a vacuum, start building in reality.

📊 Meta Launches ‘Opportunity Score’ for All Advertisers

Meta is now rolling out its Opportunity Score system-wide, giving every advertiser a quick way to evaluate and upgrade their ad campaigns based on Meta’s internal best practices.

The Breakdown: 

You’ll see a score from 0–100 summarizing how well your campaign setup aligns with Meta’s recommendations. These include technical fixes (like formatting or missing info), as well as strategic improvements based on AI-tested best practices. The higher the score, the more of Meta’s system suggestions you’ve applied.

• The score is not based on campaign performance; it’s purely tied to how many AI recommendations you follow. That means it’s a helpful checklist, not a guarantee of success.
• Still, there’s a performance case to be made. Meta says advertisers who implemented Opportunity Score suggestions saw a 12% median decrease in cost per result during testing.
• Alongside this, Meta is expanding the Advantage+ campaign setup tools. Now, all sales and app promotion campaigns will launch with built-in AI optimizations, plus access to manual controls. 
• The Opportunity Score will apply here too, making it easier to drive results even if you’re using an automated setup. According to Meta, AI-powered campaigns saw a 7–9% improvement in CPA on average.

Why it matters: Opportunity Score simplifies performance tuning by giving advertisers a concrete roadmap for improvement. It’s not a silver bullet, but it helps bridge the gap between manual setup and Meta’s AI-backed Advantage+ systems.

🎥 Ad of the Day 

What Works:

“For Dads who weather any storm” does two things at once: It metaphorically honors fatherhood’s challenges (emotional branding), It also directly ties to the functional product value: waterproof boots.

Each benefit, 100% waterproof, easy to clean, arch support, is not just utility, it’s thoughtful care. You’re not selling boots. You’re selling comfort, ease, and protection for the man who gives that to others.

The dark, rugged outdoor setting contrasts with the crisp white font and yellow annotation lines. It draws the eye from the headline down to each product benefit, guiding viewers without distraction.

Broader Insights:

The ad is high-clarity, zero-fluff. It honors the buyer’s relationship (dad), highlights tangible value (waterproof, arch support), and fits a seasonal moment. It works because it's rooted in empathy + function.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳