Deliver More Than Products!

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🎁 Unboxing Magic: How Experiential Mailers Turn Customers into Superfans

📉 Digital Ads Cost More, Convert Less

🎥 Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Drivepoint

📈 Free: 3 Advanced Forecasting Templates for Omnichannel Brands built by Drivepoint—trusted by True Classic, Oats Overnight, and Salt & Stone!

Scaling across DTC, retail, or wholesale? Stop guessing—start forecasting with confidence. 

Drivepoint, the strategic finance platform behind True Classic, Oats Overnight, and Salt & Stone, is giving you free forecasting templates to help omnichannel brands scale smarter. 🚀

Track ad spend, prevent stockouts, manage COGS, and forecast revenue—all in one place. These plug-and-play Excel templates will give you a pro-level jumpstart. 

When you’re ready for automated data syncing, real-time scenario modeling, and hyper-accurate forecasting, Drivepoint is your go-to platform.

📊 Download your free forecasting templates here!

🎁 Unboxing Magic: How Experiential Mailers Turn Customers into Superfans

In a world where digital ads fight for attention, the one-moment brands have their customers’ undivided focus? When they open that package. 

A well-crafted unboxing experience isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s an emotional trigger, a storytelling moment, and an influencer campaign all in one. Done right, it turns customers into loyal fans, fuels organic virality, and drives repeat purchases without spending an extra dime on acquisition.

Why This Works for High-Growth DTC Brands

Smart brands don’t see packaging as a cost—they see it as a conversion tool. Here’s how experiential mailers drive serious ROI:

• The Brain Loves Surprises – Neuroscience proves that unexpected delights trigger dopamine, reinforcing positive brand associations and increasing retention.

• Shareability = Free Marketing – Stunning packaging, unique inserts, or interactive elements turn customers into content creators, unlocking viral reach.

• Perceived Value = Higher LTV – A premium, well-thought-out unboxing experience makes customers feel they’re getting more than just a product—it’s an investment in brand affinity.

Next-Level Unboxing Strategies for 2025

If you’re still just putting a logo on a box, it’s time to evolve. Here’s how high-performing DTC brands are turning unboxing into an event:

1. The ‘Easter Egg’ Effect – Hide unexpected messages, AR codes, or exclusive discounts inside the packaging to reward curiosity. Think Tesla’s hidden “whoopee cushion” mode but for e-commerce.

2. VIP Unboxings for Power Buyers – Analyze customer LTV and send out tiered packaging experiences. Your highest spenders get handwritten notes, limited-edition packaging, or early access to new products.

3. Scarcity-Driven Packaging Drops – Limited-edition unboxing experiences tied to seasonal campaigns (think Supreme-style packaging) create FOMO and push urgency.

4. Multi-Touchpoint Personalization – Instead of generic inserts, integrate purchase history—like a QR code leading to a customized thank-you video or recommended product quiz.

5. ASMR-Worthy Unboxings – Premium textures, magnetic closures, or well-designed layers create a sensory experience that’s intentionally crafted to be recorded and shared.

The Data-Backed Playbook for Experiential Mailers

“To see how tactile brand moments drive viral buzz, flip through Motion’s 2025 Creative Trends—the data shows experiential mailers are more than just pretty boxes.”

It's packed with insights from $100M+ in ad spend and 500+ DTC advertisers, revealing how today’s top brands use high-impact packaging to deepen customer loyalty and supercharge organic reach.

Final Takeaway

In an era where CAC is climbing and attention spans are shrinking, experiential mailers are one of the most underutilized retention levers in DTC. The best brands don’t just ship products—they create unforgettable moments that keep customers coming back.

Ready to turn your packaging into an obsession-worthy experience?

📉 Digital Ads Cost More, Convert Less: Frustration To Blame
Insights from SEJ

New data confirms what many marketers have suspected—organic traffic is declining, ad costs are rising, and user frustrations are making conversions harder than ever.

The Breakdown

🔹 Traffic Costs Keep Climbing: Global website traffic fell 3.3% YoY, with paid traffic rising to 39% of total visits as brands spend more to compensate. Meanwhile, digital ad costs increased by 13.2%, pushing the cost per visit up 9% YoY and 19% over two years.

🔹 User Frustration Hurts Engagement: New visitors view 1.8% fewer pages, and “rage clicks” (clicking repeatedly due to site frustration) occur in one out of three sessions. Sites that reduced frustration saw 18% higher retention rates than their competitors.

🔹 Conversion Rates Are Dropping: Global conversion rates declined by 6.1%, worsened by low-performing paid traffic (1.83%) compared to unpaid channels (2.66%). High-performing brands boosted conversions by 5.4% through better engagement strategies.

🔹 Retention Begins On-Site: Despite a 7% drop in 30-day retention, returning visits grew 1.9%, driven by paid ads (+5.6%). Sites with 17% fewer rage clicks and 18% more page views per visit saw stronger customer loyalty.

Why It Matters

With ads costing more but converting less, marketers must shift focus to traffic diversification, visitor experience improvements, and frustration reduction. Winning brands proactively address engagement barriers and leverage behavioral data to maximize retention and conversions.

🎥 Ad of the Day

What Works:

"No More 3AM Wake Ups" is a powerful and specific pain point that resonates with sleep-deprived consumers. It’s not just about better sleep—it’s about fixing a disruptive issue many people experience.

Highlighting "Natural Ingredients," "No Hormones," and "Melatonin Free" reassures potential buyers who may have concerns about dependency, side effects, or grogginess.

The clean, calming aesthetic—with a simple bedside setting and a glass of water—subtly reinforces relaxation and bedtime rituals.

3 AM

The logo "knocked" is tucked away at the bottom, making it easy to miss. Integrating it into the main visual area—perhaps near the bottle or in a more prominent position—would ensure better brand retention.

Broader Insights:

The ad effectively uses specificity ("3 AM Wake Ups") rather than a generic claim like "better sleep," making it more impactful.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳