From eye-roll to add-to-cart

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🔁 From eye-roll to add-to-cart: Convert skeptics by letting creators challenge, not cheerlead.

🧠 Deterministic vs. Probabilistic: The Two Pillars of Marketing Measurement

 🏆 Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Growth School

🚀 Proven Roadmap to Making $100k Using LinkedIn & AI

It shocks me how few people leverage LinkedIn to its full potential, even in 2025.

And if you think it’s just a job-hunting platform, think again!

This 2-hour workshop on LinkedIn will explain everything and teach you how to:

👉 Automate lead generation to scale your business effortlessly.
👉 Dominate LinkedIn's $100K strategy and watch your revenue soar
👉 Leverage AI to land high-paying roles without drowning in job applications.

💰 Valued at $399, but it's FREE for the first 100 participants.

Claim Your Free Spot!

🔁 From eye-roll to add-to-cart: Convert skeptics by letting creators challenge, not cheerlead.

Most creator campaigns start with belief. But the most powerful stories in marketing aren’t about belief, they’re about surrender.

In saturated, over-promised categories, belief feels fake. What buyers crave is a public breakdown of resistance. They want to see someone fight the hype and lose.

The Creator-as-Antagonist Funnel flips the script.

You cast creators who start with skepticism, call out your brand, and still convert in public. Not with hype, with reluctance, tension, and earned trust.

Why This Works

Because belief earned in conflict sticks harder than belief gifted. When buyers see someone challenge the pitch, question the price, doubt the results, and then choose to convert anyway, it doesn’t feel like persuasion.

It feels like truth surfacing despite ego. Buyers don’t trust endorsements. They trust conversion arcs where resistance is real.

How to Build the Antagonist Arc

1. Pick the myth your category needs to kill.Find the false belief that blocks trust (e.g., “expensive = effective,” “all AI tools are generic,” “collagen doesn’t work”).
2. Source creators who actually hold that belief.Not actors. Not fans. People with tension in their voice, not polished. Modash helps find creators with real category resistance or past skepticism in their content footprint. You can start your 14-day free trial here - no credit card needed!
3. Structure the arc: conflict → curiosity → collapse.Let the creator challenge, test, observe, and then reluctantly change their mind. That visible resistance shift is your conversion trigger.

Plug-and-Play Breakdown Template

Use this structure to brief creators:

• Start with defiance: “I’ve ignored this brand for months. I thought it was all hype.”
• Introduce tension: “But a friend swore by it. So I gave it 7 days.”
• Deliver the collapse: “I hate that I liked it. But… here we are.”

Optional: Layer in data, feeling, or outcome at the moment of surrender.

Why It’s Worth Building

Because buyers today are fluent in UGC. They can spot an endorsement in three seconds. But when they see someone lose an internal argument, they feel like they just witnessed something raw and honest.

That’s not content. That’s credibility, and in 2025, credibility is the only performance channel that scales.

🧠 Deterministic vs. Probabilistic: The Two Pillars of Marketing Measurement

Marketers are finally talking about the split between deterministic and probabilistic attribution. With signal loss rising and budgets tightening, understanding when to use each method is critical. 

The Breakdown:

1. Deterministic is exact, but fading fast -  It ties conversions directly to user actions, clicks, opens, and IDs. Platforms like Meta and Google rely on this model for campaign attribution. But with iOS changes and cookie deprecation, deterministic visibility is shrinking.

2. Probabilistic steps in when data breaks down - It uses statistical models to infer what likely happened when hard data is missing. This is essential for measuring channels like podcasts, TV, or out-of-home. While less precise, it gives marketers insight when deterministic touchpoints are unavailable. 

3. They serve different roles, and should be used together - Deterministic works best for real-time creative testing and lower-funnel execution. Probabilistic is better for budget planning and measuring brand lift or multi-touch impact. Smart marketers blend both to understand now vs. forecast what's next.

Over-relying on deterministic data will leave blind spots. Too much probabilistic modeling risks imprecision. Mastering both gives marketers the edge to adapt, scale, and stay data-confident in a post-cookie world.

🎥 Ad of the Day

What Works:

The ad doesn’t just list features, it contrasts the product directly with things people already understand: eggs, apples, shakes, pasta. This anchoring technique helps viewers quickly grasp the benefits through context that they already trust. 

“30,950+ 5-star reviews” in bold yellow stars at the top adds instant credibility. It’s the Bandwagon Effect in action, when consumers see mass validation, hesitation drops. The copy “Better Bones, Better Health” adds an easy-to-digest promise (literally and metaphorically).

The layout is cleanly divided left vs right: Product and brand on one side, visual facts on the other. Bright red callouts with icons ensure each claim stands on its own and grabs attention quickly. The use of icons (egg, apple, shake, bowl) increases skimmability and cross-platform readability.

Broader Insights:

This is a retention and replenishment-focused ad dressed as acquisition. It isn’t trying to introduce bone broth, it’s reframing it as the ultimate replacement product for everyday staples. That’s what makes it powerful. It’s not competing with other broths. It’s replacing your breakfast. 

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳