Scaling is masking weakness?

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🫣 Scaling is masking weakness?

📲 TikTok’s AI Ads and Shop Tools Level Up

🏆 Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Shipfusion

Most brands think fulfillment is a backend function. Your customers experience it as the brand itself.

Shipfusion placed five real orders across leading clear protein brands and tracked everything after checkout, from tracking visibility and delivery speed options to unboxing and post-purchase communication. 

What they found explains why repeat purchases quietly drop off. Here’s what stood out immediately:

• 0 brands used exterior or interior branding, so every box arrived forgettable
• Only 40% offered more than one delivery speed, limiting customer control
• Most post-purchase emails stopped at confirmations instead of building trust

Want to know how your brand stacks up? 

If you ship products to customers, this report gives you a clear, benchmarked look at what great post-purchase checkout experiences actually include and where brands are leaving revenue on the table.

Download the DTC Delivery Files and audit your post-checkout experience today.

🫣Scaling is masking weakness?

There’s a moment in every account when spend goes up, results hold for a while, and everyone feels relieved.

That relief is usually misplaced.

When ads are doing the heavy lifting instead of extending momentum, performance becomes fragile. You’re no longer scaling demand. You’re compensating for gaps elsewhere in the system.

The mechanism is subtle. Paid media is exceptionally good at creating temporary belief. Strong creative, plus a discount, can push hesitant buyers over the line even when the offer itself isn’t fully convincing. The problem shows up later, when you try to remove the pressure.

Pull back the promo and conversion drops. Increase spend and efficiency worsens. The channel isn’t failing. It’s revealing that ads were propping up weak fundamentals.

I’ve seen this play out most clearly when brands test promo-free periods. On paper, everything looks ready to scale: solid CTRs, acceptable CAC, stable creative. But the moment urgency disappears, demand evaporates. That’s not a traffic issue. It’s a signal that pricing, positioning, or perceived value never stood on their own.

The cost of ignoring this is structural. When ads carry the business, every growth lever becomes harder to pull. You can’t raise prices without resistance. You can’t reduce discounts without volume loss. You can’t slow spend without revenue volatility. Marketing becomes a treadmill, not an engine.

The fix isn’t “less ads.” It’s restoring the proper division of labor.

Product and positioning should create belief. Pricing should make the decision feel rational. Ads should amplify what already works, not manufacture conviction under pressure.

A practical way to diagnose this is to isolate normal days. Look at conversion, AOV, and retention during periods with no promos, no launches, no artificial urgency. If performance collapses there, ads aren’t scaling demand. They’re masking a weak core.

This doesn’t mean promos are bad. They’re accelerants. Used correctly, they pull forward demand that already exists. Used incorrectly, they become the only reason demand shows up at all.

When ads are extending momentum, scaling feels boring. Small spend increases lead to predictable output. When ads are carrying the business, scaling feels dramatic and stressful, because every dollar is fighting gravity.

Growth becomes durable when ads stop acting like life support and start behaving like leverage.

📲 TikTok’s AI Ads and Shop Tools Level Up

TikTok is upgrading how advertisers build and scale campaigns inside Smart+, while also making TikTok Shop content faster to produce. These updates are all about reducing manual work without fully giving up control. If you run DTC ads, this is more leverage with fewer steps.

The Breakdown:

1. AI Fashion Video Maker for TikTok Shop - TikTok Shop is rolling out AI Fashion Video Maker, which turns still product images into ready-to-run video clips in minutes. It can add voiceovers, music, and movement automatically. 

TikTok also added “List with AI” to turn a photo and short description into a full product listing. It’s shipping CRM connection upgrades, Judge.me reviews, and GMV Max campaigns to streamline promotions and conversion.

2. Smart+ Auto-Picks Winning Creatives - Smart+ now has “Auto-select,” which scans your existing ads plus eligible creator content from TikTok One. It then recommends the best-performing creatives based on your campaign goals. 

TikTok now lets you preview every possible creative combination inside Ads Manager before anything goes live. That means fewer surprise placements, faster approvals, and quicker iteration.

TikTok is also opening up measurement beyond the app with Off-site Performance Analysis, using a pixel to connect TikTok engagement to purchases on your website. That matters because it links organic, Live, Shop, and paid ads to real off-platform revenue. It’s a clear push to prove impact outside TikTok’s walls.

Together with Section

The AI Marketing Systems You Can Implement Tomorrow - January 29 | Free Virtual Event

If you’re still “experimenting” with AI while your team ships the same campaigns, you’re not early, you’re late. 

On Jan 29 (12 to 4 PM ET), join Section’s free virtual AI Marketing Strategy Summit featuring Scott Galloway (Professor of Marketing, NYU Stern) and a tight lineup of leaders who’ve actually built modern growth systems.

• Get the AI marketing moves that drive measurable lift
• Learn what matters in 2026 so you stop chasing shiny tools
• Walk away with strategies you can deploy the very next day

Featuring Kieran Flanagan (SVP of Marketing, HubSpot), Aude Gandon (Chief Digital & Marketing Officer, Estée Lauder), and Dan Slagen (SVP of Marketing, Zapier).

Claim your free spot!

🏆 Ad of the Day

What Works:

The Bold Move - They say “ADHD” out loud. Most brands dance around it, this one names it directly, which instantly grabs the exact person who’s scrolling while overstimulated.

What It’s Really Promising - Not silence. Control. “Find focus” is the outcome people want, and “earplugs” is the simple tool that makes it feel achievable without a lifestyle overhaul.

Where This Wins In The Funnel - This is a cold-start attention grab. It’s built to pull in the right niche fast, then let the site and reviews do the heavier explaining.

If your product solves a very specific problem, don’t water it down. Call out the exact person you’re for, and make the solution feel stupidly simple.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳