Your Dashboard is Lying

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

📉 Why MER Alone Can’t Save You: The metric that made you feel in control might be the one holding you back.

📲 Meta Doubles Down on Messaging with New WhatsApp Ad Tools

🚀Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Jira

Jira is the best cross-functional tool for project management

For 20 years, Jira has been the #1 choice for agile software teams to manage the delivery of incredible projects. Now, Jira is flexible and easy to use for any team.

With AI in Jira, you can capture tasks from Slack or Microsoft Teams, write a complete description, create subtasks based on your previous work, and find and attach relevant work and resources.

So your teams, instead of working in siloed spreadsheets, can move forward with all the context they need to move their big ideas from due to done. 

That’s how Jira helped:

Reddit break down silos between teams and Roblox save 150K annually.

Get started for free (forever) for up to ten users.

Learn more!

📉 Why MER Alone Can’t Save You: The metric that made you feel in control might be the one holding you back.

In the chaos of blended attribution and platform inflation, MER (Marketing Efficiency Ratio) emerged as the fallback compass. Simple math: total revenue divided by total ad spend. For a while, it was the sanity metric. But for 7- and 8-figure brands chasing real profit, MER is now too blunt, too delayed, and too easily manipulated by one-off spikes.

It’s not wrong. It’s just insufficient.

1. MER Is a Map, Not a GPS

MER shows you if spend is working at the highest level, but it tells you nothing about where margin is leaking or which channels are delivering actual incrementality. A 4.2x MER might look amazing, but if it’s fueled by a blowout TikTok UGC campaign that tanks repeat rate or by discount-driven spikes, you’ve got a short-term illusion and long-term rot.

Fix: Pair MER with Contribution Margin, post-ad-spend, post-COGS, post-fulfillment. That’s where profitability hides.

2. CAC Trendlines Expose Hidden Decay

Most brands report CAC weekly. Elite brands track trendlines against spend growth and discount depth. A flat MER with rising CAC and shrinking rebuy windows? That’s an efficiency trap. You’re overspending just to keep the illusion of stability.

Fix: Layer CAC trendlines into your dashboards with context like offer shifts, channel weights, and inventory constraints. Then judge campaigns not just by average CAC, but marginal CAC per $10K of additional spend.

3. MER Slicing Shows Which Channels Are Freeloading

Aggregate MER is a blended number, so it hides freeloaders, channels that claim conversions but drive no incremental volume. That retargeting ad is soaking up 30% of the spend? It’s not moving the needle. Your MER doesn’t care. But you're aMER, acquisition-only MER absolutely will.

Fix: Segment MER by acquisition versus retention flows. Add aMER views per channel. It’s the only way to know where to trim fat without killing growth.

Why It Matters: MER made sense when visibility collapsed. But now that margins are tight, every point of waste hurts 3× more. Profit-first scaling isn’t about finding better creatives; it’s about measuring the right impact with surgical precision. MER can’t save you anymore. But the right metrics stack can.

📲 Meta Doubles Down on Messaging with New WhatsApp Ad Tools

Meta just unveiled new messaging-focused ad features that tightly integrate WhatsApp into Ads Manager, allowing brands to manage multi-platform campaigns in one workflow and deploy AI-driven automation for personalized messaging. 

The Breakdown:

1. Unified Campaign Setup with WhatsApp Ads – Advertisers can now manage WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, and Messenger campaigns from a single interface. Creative assets and budgets sync automatically, with Advantage+ AI optimizing performance across placements.

2. Business AIs Get Smarter and More Personalized – Brands can build WhatsApp chatbots using Meta’s AI tools to offer recommendations and answer queries. These bots support lead nurturing, follow-ups, and embedded purchase flows within conversations.

3. Direct Calling and Voice Support for Complex Queries - Large businesses on WhatsApp Business Platform can now initiate or receive voice and video calls directly with customers. Voice messaging is also being introduced to expand communication options.

As messaging overtakes feed-based engagement, Meta is realigning its ad infrastructure around DMs and automation. These WhatsApp updates reflect a larger trend: brands moving toward always-on, conversational commerce powered by AI. With WhatsApp’s scale, these tools could become a key pillar in Meta’s next-gen business suite .

📖 Ebook

Your audience isn’t yours. Your email list is.

One algorithm change and your reach is gone. This free ebook from GetResponse shows you how to turn followers into subscribers, and subscribers into customers you actually own.

✅ 3-step funnel to convert traffic into email leads
✅ Ready-to-use automations that drive sales while you sleep
✅ Real brand examples of scaling beyond social
✅ A self-audit checklist to fix what’s holding you back

Build the list that builds your business.

Download the free ebook now!

🎥 Ad of the Day

What Works:

1. Emotional Anchoring Through Identity Signals - Each case is tied to a zodiac sign, which taps directly into identity-based marketing. People feel emotionally connected to their signs, so showcasing Scorpio, Cancer, and Pisces creates immediate relatability, tribal belonging, and “this one’s for me” energy.

2. Accessory Inclusion = Value Amplification - Each case is shown with a beaded phone chain, a trending Gen Z accessory that adds playfulness and function. This positions the product as more than a case: it’s a fashion item and statement piece.

Broader Insights:

Astrology is one of the most normalized forms of modern tribal marketing. Tied to emotional qualities associated with each sign. This shifts a functional product into a deeply expressive purchase.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳