When Add to Cart Bleeds Ads

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🛒 When Add to Cart Slips, the Ad Is Bleeding

🔍 Lower CPCs Reveal Bigger Acquisition Problems Ahead

🏆 Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Cloudways

This Q5, Scale Beyond Limits with Cloudways

Cloudways gives marketers, freelancers, and agencies the power to host unlimited sites, scale instantly, and deliver fast performance without traditional hosting hassles. 

Built a high-speed NGINX stack and supported by 24/7 expert support, it lets you focus on building and growing projects that actually move the needle.

Choose from five top cloud providers like DigitalOcean, AWS, Google Cloud, and more, pay-as-you-go plans, and let Cloudways Copilot handle the heavy lifting of server maintenance.

This Q5, you can get 30% off for 3 months + 50 free migrations. Your hosting shouldn’t slow you down; it should help you grow.

Claim Your Cloudways Offer Today!

🛒 When Add to Cart Slips, the Ad Is Bleeding

The quickest way to waste money is to diagnose a creative problem using the slowest metric you have.

ROAS is a lagging headline, not the crime scene. By the time it moves, you are already paying for the mistake.

If you want to know whether an ad deserves budget, you do not need a full funnel autopsy. You need three checkpoints that tell the truth fast, before attribution muddies everything.

The Operator Rule

An ad earns the right to live only if it can do three jobs in order.

Stop the scroll. Pull the click at a sane price. Produce real intent, not just browsing.

That is it.

1. Stop using ROAS as your first question

ROAS is a messy blend of timing, attribution windows, retargeting overlap, channel spillover, and day-level randomness.

It is also heavily influenced by what happened before the ad, like brand demand, email, creators, and seasonality.

So when you open Ads Manager and start with ROAS, you are starting with the most contaminated signal. You are reading the ending and pretending it explains the plot.

2. CTR tells you if the idea even landed

CTR is not a vanity number when you interpret it correctly.

It is the simplest test of relevance: did the message interrupt autopilot scrolling or not?

If CTR is soft, do not blame the audience or the algorithm. The angle did not bite. The hook did not earn attention. Nothing downstream will rescue it.

3. CPC is the platform’s honesty meter

CPC is Meta telling you, in plain numbers, how hard it is to find people who actually care.

Cheap CPC usually means the message has natural pull and the auction is not fighting you.

High CPC means you are forcing distribution into people who are not leaning in. Even if you get conversions, you are buying them the hard way, which usually collapses when you scale.

4. Add to Cart is the first moment that matters

Clicks are curiosity. Add to cart is the intent.

This is where the customer stops being polite and starts being serious.

If CTR is fine and CPC is fine, but add to cart drops, the ad and the page are misaligned. The promise got them to the door, but the page, offer, price, or expectation match failed to carry the story forward.

The compression check

Before you touch bidding, budget, or “creative iterations,” answer these three questions:

• Did the idea earn attention, CTR?
• Did the market accept it at scale, CPC?
• Did the promise survive contact with reality? Add to cart.

If those hold, the ad is structurally alive, and ROAS swings are usually timing and noise.

If those fail, kill it fast, fix the story, and stop paying tuition for a weak premise.

🔍 Lower CPCs Reveal Bigger Acquisition Problems Ahead

This week’s Northbeam data tells a clear story for DTC operators: traffic is getting cheaper, but customers are getting harder to win. Falling CPCs paired with rising CAC and shrinking ROAS show that the real battle is shifting from acquisition volume to conversion quality.

The Breakdown:

1. CPC - CPCs dropped almost everywhere, with Meta, TikTok, and Pinterest leading the fall, which signals cheaper reach but also hints that algorithms are prioritising low-intent users who look efficient on paper but rarely convert. 

2. CAC - CAC climbed across all platforms, including Google and Snap, showing that even with falling CPCs, the cost to acquire real buyers is rising because lower-intent traffic puts more pressure on product pages, offers, and on-site persuasion.

3. ROAS - ROAS declined on Meta (-17.61%), Google (-19.27%), and Pinterest (-18.08%), proving that cheap clicks aren’t translating into profitable sales because ad relevance and landing-page alignment are slipping, forcing brands to rethink messaging cohesion rather than chase efficiency metrics.

Budget share shifted meaningfully, with Google gaining +10.85% and Pinterest +6.74%, while TikTok (-24.58%) and Meta (-5.44%) lost ground, reminding marketers that the real unlock now lies in rebuilding intent, tightening creative-to-offer alignment, and strengthening mid-funnel conversion paths.

Together with Galactic Fed

This 20-minute growth session could save you millions.

Looking for growth answers in all the wrong places?

Now's your chance to meet 1:1 with Galactic Fed's advisors. They will understand your business, audit your channels, and show you where the fastest growth opportunities are hiding.

Their team’s data comes from managing millions in ad spend across 600+ brands like Quiznos, Varo, and Edible. They'll apply all that insight to your marketing.

It’s free, it’s personalized, and it’s the same process that’s helped clients get funded, acquired, and go from startup to standout.

🎥 Ad of the Day

What Works:

1. Sold-Out Proof - “SOLD OUT 4x already” does the persuasion for you. It feels like other people already tested it, so you’re just catching the next drop before it disappears again.

2. Costco Trust - “Now at Costco” instantly makes it feel legit, not gimmicky. If Costco carries it, it passed a quality filter, and the price probably won’t feel like a regret.

3. Gift Feels Easy - Open box, ribbons, bowls of popcorn, it screams “holiday gift” without saying it. You can picture giving it and looking thoughtful, with zero extra planning.

It works because it feels like snagging something popular before it’s gone, not being sold to. Proof, trust, humor, and giftability stack into a decision that feels obvious.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳