When Winning Tests Lose You the Long Game

Howdy readers 🥰

In this newsletter, you’ll find:

🚨 When Winning Tests Lose You the Long Game

🛡️ TikTok's Full-Spectrum Ad Safety Toolkit

🏆 Ad of the Day

If you’re new to ScaleUP, then a hearty welcome! You and 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers have reached the right place. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!

Together with Levanta

Amazon’s not broken. But your mix might be.

If your Amazon growth is slowing while ad spend keeps rising, it’s probably not the platform—it’s your strategy.

Top brands like HyperIce, Caraway, and Goli are shifting their spend to something smarter:

Performance-based affiliate marketing that drives high-quality external traffic and only costs money when it converts.

Why it works:

✅ Drive traffic from trusted creators, publishers, and review sites
✅ Boost your organic rankings by bringing in off-Amazon traffic
✅ Get paid via Amazon’s Brand Referral Bonus
✅ Only pay for performance—not impressions or clicks

With Levanta, you get access to a vetted network of over 10,000 creators—plus the tools to track performance, optimize your program, and grow sales without wasting spend.

Curious what kind of lift this could drive for your brand?

Get your Projection for free today!

🚨 When Winning Tests Lose You the Long Game

You run a test. You toss on a “bestseller” badge. Reorder a grid. CVR jumps 12%. Feels like a win, so you lock it in.

Fast forward a few weeks, and sales flatten out again. But now your newer SKUs are invisible. Your returning customers keep buying the same 3 products. Discovery’s dead.

That wasn’t a win. That was a false signal dressed up like success.

Novelty Lifts Are Real—But They Don’t Last

Most “wins” in CRO aren’t long-term improvements. They’re spikes—short dopamine hits from new layouts, surprise copy, or social proof tweaks.

“Bestseller” tags? They work for a while. But lean on them too often, and you train shoppers to ignore everything else. That’s where portfolio fatigue creeps in:

• People stop browsing, they scan for badges
• High-margin or new products stall out
• You start competing with yourself

So yeah, CVR looked good on the dashboard. But you narrowed the buyer’s world, and long-term, that costs more than the lift gave you.

When a “Win” Starts to Hurt

It’s not just about one variant. The problem shows up in roadmap decisions, merchandising strategy, and even paid spend.

• You start overinvesting in products that got an artificial boost
• Your funnel gets tuned for clicks, not for discovery
• Your brand starts to feel… predictable

You think you’ve found a lever, but you’ve actually blocked the next one.

What to Do Instead

1. Re-Test Your Winners at 30–60 Days

No CRO win should be assumed permanent. Come back after the dust settles. If the lift fades, it was novelty, not value.

2. Rotate Social Proof, Don’t Anchor It

Highlight “popular” and “new” dynamically. Let different products breathe. Use badges to shape behavior, not lock it in.

3. Use Tools That Let You Pull Back Fast

This is where Stellar is clutch—you can spin up and roll back A/B tests without dev or delay. If a win turns sideways, you’re not stuck with it, so go on and book your free test run with Stellar—no credit card required.

Final Thought

CRO isn’t about chasing nice charts. It’s about building a product environment that stays alive. If you’re not testing for decay, you’re just gambling on novelty. And that’s not optimization. That’s roulette.

🛡️ TikTok's Full-Spectrum Ad Safety Toolkit
Insights from Social Media Today

TikTok has rolled out a comprehensive upgrade to its brand safety and suitability tools, giving advertisers unprecedented control over where their ads appear, how they perform. Alongside this, TikTok released a 43-page Brand Safety and Suitability Playbook detailing every layer of these protections.

The Breakdown:

1. Pre-Campaign Control Tools - Advertisers now get fine-tuned control before campaigns even launch. Tools like Inventory Filter, Category Exclusion, and Vertical Sensitivity let brands avoid unsafe or off-brand environments—from gambling to gaming to finance. This allows campaigns to begin with contextual alignment built-in.

2. In-Flight Adjustments for Live Campaigns - With Video Exclusion Lists, marketers can block specific videos by ID in near real-time, while Profile Feed Exclusion Lists help remove entire creator feeds. Comment Management adds an extra layer by letting advertisers disable, hide, or filter comments for brand-safe engagement during live runs.

3. Post-Campaign Safety Auditing - TikTok’s brand safety program now integrates third-party post-campaign measurement. Partners like IAS, DV, and Zefr provide analytics across six dimensions: brand safety, brand suitability, category & vertical exclusion rates, and even misinformation rates.

With flexible pre-, mid-, and post-campaign controls, it sets a new bar in platform-level ad control, especially valuable in an era where one misplaced ad can spark reputational damage. All of these capabilities are available in the Brand Safety Hub within TikTok Ads Manager. 

🎥 Ad of the Day

What Works:

The use of smoke, shadows, and monochrome black evokes a strong sense of mystery, masculinity, and rebellion. These visual cues appeal to consumers seeking bold, edgy, or "alpha" identity associations. 

The word “SMOKE” is crafted to look like it’s made of smoke, blending motion with texture, making the name feel visceral.

The hat is presented at a cinematic angle, lit to highlight depth, texture, and craftsmanship. The smoke swirls around it like it's emerging from a fire, implying heat, exclusivity, and limited-edition energy.

This ad isn’t just selling a cap, it’s selling a persona. The dark aesthetic and clean design appeal to the status-driven streetwear consumer who seeks subtle but sharp self-expression.

The minimalist approach ensures it doesn't "sell" aggressively, it seduces the viewer instead.

Broader Insights:

This is stealth marketing done right. No price, no pitch, just attitude, mystery, and bold aesthetic alignment. It works because it makes the viewer feel cool just by looking at it, triggering aspirational emotions. That’s when conversion gets personal.

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Find our Partner Kit here🤝

We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.

At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰

Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳